Clicky Web Analytics
presentation
documentation
creation
automation
bim after dark live

Monday, January 7, 2013

"So, you're not really 'doing' BIM?"

Today, I sat through a long and boring plan review required by out state.  Being such a long and boring meeting (literally eight hours with a break for lunch) I had to find a way to pass time while I was not participating.  Luckily there was one part of the meeting that got my mind moving.

The state in which our project is located happens to "require BIM".  Of course, the people who enforce this requirement have no experience with building information modeling.  Well, there are some forms or letters that have to be submitted to, I guess, prove you are using BIM on the project.  The reviewer read the letter and then asked "are all of the documents produced using a 'BIM software?".

Without getting on my soapbox (you never want to get on a soapbox at a meeting like this... lots of power hungry reviewers out there). I answered stating that the architecture, MEP, and structural drawings were all created and coordinated using Revit while the consultants (landscape, civil, food service, and technology) used AutoCAD.  The reviewer responded:

"So, you're not doing BIM then?"

My mind immediately began to wander.  If we see BIM as the process is it software dependent?  If we see BIM as the software then is the process dependent on such software?  I know there are many other questions embedded in this little story and I would love to hear all of your thoughts on my aforementioned experience?



Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
K Fielding's avatar

K Fielding · 639 weeks ago

Great post, this is a superb example of how many clients are still uneducated as to what BIM (the process) is.

'Anybody know where I can buy some BIM?' :)

The biggest issue with BIM is the ambiguity of the acronym. There is often over emphasis of the Model and not the Information. They would have been better to announce it as Building Information Management, as I prefer.
K.Gallegos's avatar

K.Gallegos · 639 weeks ago

I would agree 100%. We have clients that ask for BIM with no idea what they want. It begs the comparison to LEED. A couple years ago everyone thought they wanted their building LEED certified. (or as they would say "we want a LEEDS building." These days the buzz word is BIM. The best way to spread the knowledge is to ask questions of them as what their understanding of BIM is and what they want to accomplish with it. It most likely is that they just want the design coordinated more for less surprises (additional costs) during construction. Explain the differences and advantages your firm offers with your BIM design process and how they can utilize that "Information Management" and those clients should come back.
I always chuckle to myself when I get the "BIM" question from folks on the fringe of our industry. I respond with, "I was doing BIM back in AutoCAD 10 for UNIX". Heavily attributed blocks and tags with text files being generated by LiSP routines, calls from C (not C# or C++), more LiSP and early work with Wavefront Tech. for visualization/animation.

Much simpler these days of course. I had the California Courts (AOC) ask for my input on what they should require for BIM. I asked them why they wanted BIM as a requirement. That opened a whole can-o-worms.

Post a new comment

Comments by