Clicky Web Analytics
presentation
documentation
creation
automation
bim after dark live
Showing posts with label demolition views and room names. Show all posts
Showing posts with label demolition views and room names. Show all posts

Monday, September 5, 2011

Revit Tip - Phasing and Room Names - Revisited...

Michael, one of your fellow readers, brought up a great point to the little tip I posted about Phasing, Demo, and Room Names:

"Having a separate Demo phase is definitely not the way to do it. It is a work around for the existing rooms problem but raises further issues. 
What happens when you place a new door into an existing wall? It demos that part of the wall in the same phase as the new door was placed. If you have a separate demo phase before the new door was placed then that demolished wall won't show up in your demo drawings because it wasn't yet demolished in that phase."
That is an excellent point... And, of course, brings us full circle to my very first post about Room Name Frustrations...

This is why I love when you guys comment and start a dialogue... The three aforementioned posts are perfect examples of how great and informative these conversations can be..

Now, what do we do about these Room Names?!?!


Friday, September 2, 2011

Revit Tip - Phasing - Demo Existing and New Room Names

I posted a few days ago about some frustrations I was having with the Rooms and phasing of Revit.  Well, turns out a simple change of my thought process on Phasing helped out a lot... Thanks to a comment by a reader named Marty M!

First, we must remember that Room's exist on the phase they were placed on.  That is to say, whatever phase your view is set to when you place a room, that is the room's phase.

Second, your project should have a minimum three phases (as opposed to the Autodesk template of only two): Existing, Demolition, and New Construction. I say minimum because this is all based on the project.  You may have more than three.  ***EDIT*** DEMO IS NOT A PHASE!!

Build your existing building and add all the room names in the Existing Phase.

Now that you have all three phases set up and views for each phase.  Everything that you demolish should be demolished on the "Demolition" Phase... Not the "New Construction" Phase.  This is where my mind set had to change a bit.  I had always set the "Phase Demolished" to "New Construction" and I think it was due to the Revit Template only started with two phases. **Note**  When using the Demolition "Hammer" from the tool bar make sure you are in the Demolition phase view.  The hammer sets the elements demo phase to whatever view you are in. ***

Finally, in your Demo floor plans... Set the phase to "Demolition" and set the phase filter to "Show Previous + Demo"...  Go back to your Existing floor plan with the room names and select all the Rooms... (Not the Room Names... you want to select the blue squares).  Copy to your clipboard, and paste the Rooms into your demolition view.

Tah dah!  Now you have your Existing Room names in your Demo views...

Of course, the one caveat is that you are managing two sets of Existing Rooms.





Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Room Phasing Frustrations!

How many of you have used Revit and Phasing?  Specifically, Demolition plans...  How many of you have pondered this very question:

"Why would New Construction room names want to been seen on a Demolition Plan?!?!?!"

Recently, I was working on a project that has over nine part plans...  The only work around for getting your Existing Room names (that I have found useful) is to create an Existing Room Names view that only shows Existing Room names. Then, place the demolition view on the sheet and overlay the existing room names over it.  This worked out fine on most of the projects.  Unfortunately, creating nine part plan views of existing room names for four levels and then overlaying them on top of their respective views on sheets drove me absolutely crazy!

Example of New Rooms showing in "Previous + New" Phase filter.  Why!?

Why can we not phase rooms?!  Autodesk, this does not seem like a very difficult fix.  No one wants to see New Construction room names on a "Previous + Demo" filter...

Has anyone experienced this?  What is your workaround?  Comment below!